Jowhar, SOMALIA – Last night, HirShabelle Presidential Guard forces engaged in infighting, resulting in the death of one of their own. This incident is not an isolated occurrence, as another clash between these guards and the Danab special forces took place in Jowhar in November. In that incident, Danab forces ambushed HirShabelle Presidential Guard forces while they were transporting the Speaker of the HirShabelle Parliament.
These recurring clashes within the security forces tasked with protecting the HirShabelle region and its leadership raise serious concerns about their cohesion and effectiveness. The fact that these incidents involve the Presidential Guard, a unit responsible for the safety of top officials, suggests a lack of discipline, coordination, and unity among the forces at the forefront of the fight against Al-Shabab.
The timing and location of these incidents are particularly significant. Jowhar, the capital of HirShabelle, is currently besieged by Al-Shabab, with the region’s leadership relying on air travel to reach Mogadishu, just 90 kilometers to the south. The occurrence of infighting among the Presidential Guard forces while their region is under direct threat from Al-Shabab raises questions about their priorities and focus on the primary security challenge facing the region.
Implications for Somalia’s Security Apparatus
The infighting among HirShabelle forces has broader implications for Somalia’s security apparatus and its ability to effectively combat Al-Shabab. The involvement of the Danab special forces, a key component of Somalia’s counter-terrorism efforts trained and equipped by international partners, in the November ambush suggests a lack of coordination and cooperation among the various elements of Somalia’s security architecture.
This lack of unity and cohesion among security forces presents a significant vulnerability that Al-Shabab can exploit. The group has a history of manipulating local conflicts and grievances to its advantage, and the infighting among HirShabelle forces provides a potential opening for Al-Shabab to further destabilize the region and undermine the government’s authority.
The recurring nature of these incidents points to a deeper problem of weak command and control structures and a lack of accountability within the security forces. The repeated occurrence of such clashes without effective preventive measures indicates a failure of leadership and a breakdown in the chain of command. This not only undermines the effectiveness of the security forces but also erodes public trust in their ability to provide security and protect the population.
Questions About Priorities in the Fight Against Al-Shabab
The infighting among HirShabelle forces raises questions about the government’s commitment to prioritizing the fight against Al-Shabab. While the government has pledged to defeat the terrorist group and restore stability to the country, incidents like these suggest that internal divisions and conflicts within the security forces are diverting attention and resources away from this crucial task.
To effectively combat Al-Shabab and restore stability to Somalia, a comprehensive and holistic approach to security sector reform is necessary. This requires a focus on building strong command and control structures, improving coordination among different security forces, and enforcing strict discipline and accountability measures.
Additionally, addressing the underlying factors that contribute to instability and conflict, such as poor governance, corruption, and marginalization of certain communities, is crucial for creating the conditions necessary for lasting peace and security.
The infighting among HirShabelle forces serves as a stark reminder of the challenges faced by Somalia’s security apparatus in confronting the threat posed by Al-Shabab. It highlights the need for a renewed focus on building a unified, professional, and accountable security apparatus capable of effectively combating the terrorist group and restoring stability to the country.
